Introduction
Let’s be honest—shipping your car across the country isn’t like mailing a birthday card. You need a company that’s reliable, affordable, and most importantly, trustworthy. Two giants have dominated this field for years: AmeriFreight vs Montway Auto Transport. If you’re debating between the two, this detailed comparison will help you make the smartest choice for your wallet and your wheels.
📦 Understanding Auto Transport Services
What Is Auto Transport and Why Does It Matter?
Auto transport services help you move your vehicle from one location to another without you having to drive it. Whether you’re relocating, buying a car online, or sending a vehicle to a loved one, companies like AmeriFreight and Montway offer safe and efficient options.
For a deeper understanding of how auto transport works, check this guide on how car shipping works.
🏢 AmeriFreight Auto Transport Overview
Founded in 2004, AmeriFreight is a car shipping broker that connects customers with licensed, insured carriers across the U.S. They’ve built a reputation on transparent pricing, extensive coverage, and robust customer support.
Key Features:
- Offers both open and enclosed transport
- Known for excellent customer service
- Provides additional insurance through the AFta Plan
- Offers discounts to students, military, and medical personnel
Visit their official website AmeriFreight to explore services.
🚛 Montway Auto Transport Overview
Montway Auto Transport has been around since 2006 and boasts one of the largest carrier networks in the country. With over one million vehicles shipped, they offer a tech-driven, streamlined shipping experience.
Key Features:
- Competitive pricing
- No upfront payment required
- Nationwide coverage
- Strong online booking system
Check their full offerings on Montway’s official site.
💸 Price Comparison: AmeriFreight vs Montway
AmeriFreight Pricing Explained
AmeriFreight uses a pricing tier system:
- Economy: Lower cost but longer wait time
- Priority: Balanced wait time and cost
- First Class: Fastest service, premium price
They also provide a “rate lock guarantee” and gap insurance to cover what traditional insurance doesn’t.
Montway’s Pricing Structure
Montway offers instant online quotes and rarely charges upfront. Their pricing is more consistent and transparent, especially for standard open transport. They even have dynamic pricing tools to help you get the best rate in real-time.
📊 On average, Montway is slightly cheaper—especially for short distances—while AmeriFreight may cost more but offers extra security through insurance.
🔒 Insurance and Safety Coverage : AmeriFreight vs Montway
AmeriFreight’s AFta PLAN
AmeriFreight’s AFta PLAN is a standout. It fills gaps not covered by carriers’ insurance, such as:
- Deductible reimbursement
- Damage coverage during storage
- Missed delivery compensation
This is a unique feature that sets them apart.
Montway’s Coverage Policy
Montway ensures every carrier in its network is fully insured. However, they don’t offer extra coverage like AmeriFreight unless you purchase third-party insurance separately.
🛠 Services Comparison: What You Get
Shipping Options
| Service Type | AmeriFreight | Montway |
|---|---|---|
| Open Transport | ✅ Available | ✅ Available |
| Enclosed Transport | ✅ Available | ✅ Available |
| Expedited Shipping | ✅ Available | ✅ Limited Availability |
| Inoperable Vehicle | ✅ Available | ✅ Available |
| Door-to-Door Shipping | ✅ Standard | ✅ Standard |
AmeriFreight offers a more hands-on service experience, while Montway is more automated and user-driven.
🧾 Discounts and Special Offers
AmeriFreight Discounts
- Students
- Military personnel
- First responders
- Medical workers
- Multiple vehicle transport
Montway Discounts
Montway doesn’t offer as many explicit discounts, but they keep their prices naturally competitive and occasionally run promotional offers.
🌟 Customer Reviews & Satisfaction
AmeriFreight Customer Feedback
- 4.7/5 on Trustpilot
- BBB A+ rating
- Customers praise responsiveness and professionalism
Montway Customer Feedback
- 4.6/5 on Google Reviews
- BBB A+ rating
- Highlighted for timely delivery and competitive pricing
One key difference: AmeriFreight assigns a dedicated agent, while Montway operates more like Uber for car shipping—automated, fast, and efficient.
📍 Shipping Timeframes & Coverage Areas
Both companies operate nationwide, including Alaska and Hawaii (via port). Here’s how their delivery time compares:
| Distance (Miles) | AmeriFreight ETA | Montway ETA |
|---|---|---|
| 0–500 | 1–3 Days | 1–2 Days |
| 500–1000 | 2–5 Days | 2–4 Days |
| 1000+ | 4–7 Days | 4–6 Days |
Montway is usually faster due to their broader carrier network.
🛎 Booking Process: Ease of Use
AmeriFreight Booking
- Requires quote via email or call
- Personalized consultation
- Manual but customer-friendly
Montway Booking
- 100% online quote system
- No deposit needed
- Fully digital booking & tracking
For tech-savvy users, Montway feels smoother. For those who prefer a human touch, AmeriFreight wins.
📉 Cancellation & Refund Policies
- AmeriFreight: Offers free cancellation before carrier assignment
- Montway: Free cancellation anytime before dispatch
Montway is more flexible if plans change.
📋 Pros & Cons Breakdown : AmeriFreight vs Montway
AmeriFreight Pros
- Excellent insurance add-ons
- Personalized service
- Multiple discounts
- Great for first-time shippers
AmeriFreight Cons
- Slightly higher base cost
- Slower if choosing economy tier
Montway Pros
- Fast shipping
- Lower average cost
- Easy online quotes
- Great for short-distance moves
Montway Cons
- No additional insurance coverage
- Less personalized customer experience
💡 Which Company Should You Choose?
If you value security, support, and peace of mind, AmeriFreight is worth the extra few bucks.
If you’re budget-conscious and prefer a fast, efficient, self-managed system, Montway is your winner.
✅ Conclusion: The Final Verdict
When it comes to AmeriFreight vs Montway, there’s no clear-cut winner—it depends on what you value most.
- Choose AmeriFreight if you want hands-on support, premium protection, and don’t mind paying a little more.
- Pick Montway for affordability, fast delivery, and a seamless digital experience.
Both are excellent companies, but the best choice is the one that aligns with your personal needs.
READ MORE…
Top Movers in California Ranked: 2025
Top-Rated Moving Companies in Florida
How to Ship a Car from NY to FL – Fast, Safe & Affordable
❓ FAQs: AmeriFreight vs Montway
1. Is AmeriFreight worth the extra cost?
Yes, if you value top-notch insurance and personal service, AmeriFreight justifies its higher price tag.
2. Can Montway ship classic or luxury cars?
Absolutely. They offer enclosed transport specifically for high-value vehicles.
3. Are there hidden fees with either company?
No. Both companies are upfront, though AmeriFreight’s tier system can sometimes confuse newcomers.
4. Which one is better for rural areas?
AmeriFreight often does better in rural zones due to its personalized broker network.
5. How soon should I book auto transport?
Ideally, 1–2 weeks in advance. But both companies can handle last-minute requests—Montway especially excels here.ime, money, and a whole lot of stress.
1. Is AmeriFreight more expensive than Montway?
Typically, yes. AmeriFreight may charge more, especially for priority services or gap coverage. But you get what you pay for—better insurance and dedicated support.
2. Does Montway offer any discounts?
Not as many as AmeriFreight. However, their base rates are often lower, and they don’t require upfront deposits.
3. Which company is faster AmeriFreight vs Montway?
Montway usually edges out AmeriFreight in terms of shipping speed, especially in popular transport routes.
4. Are both companies licensed and insured?
Absolutely. Both are FMCSA-registered brokers with fully insured carrier networks.
5. Can I ship a non-running vehicle with either company?
Yes. Both offer options for inoperable vehicles, though you’ll need to specify this upfront, and the cost will be higher.
